How to Choose a Pie Iron

Because I use pie irons so often, I wanted to explain what kinds I use and for what purposes, because I’ve found certain designs better for particular recipes.

This website uses affiliate links. See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Pie irons are not new, and they are not complicated. They are fairly self-explanatory too — just use a lot of cooking spray and check inside often as your stuff cooks in the fire because the cast iron gets hot quick, and we don’t want burnt food. I love them because they let me cook for myself quickly with barely any clean up.

I covered pie iron basics and provided tips fairly well in my other blog in a post for Pie Iron Tater Tots. In this post, I just wanted to share specifically which pie irons I have and which I use for what types of recipes.

My Favorite Pie Iron for Savory Recipes

I use Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker the most. The reason it is my favorite is because it is roomier. It is rounded around the outer edge and provides more interior space, so my sandwiches and such don’t get smooshed.

This is also the pie iron I use for my calzones when I am camping solo, for the same reason… the space it gives allows me to load up on fillings. I also use it for biscuits because there’s plenty of room in there for the dough to expand while cooking.

A pie iron with a long handle held over glowing embers and burning logs in a fire pit

My Favorite Pie Iron for Dessert Pies

Unlike sandwiches, when I am making dessert pies, I want the edges crimped. I want the pie iron to hold the pie together more snugly regardless of whether if I am using bread or pie dough.

Dessert pie fillings are looser, sugary, creamy, and I don’t want that going anywhere but in my belly. So for these kinds of recipes, I use a different shaped Coghlan pie iron. The edge around the pie iron is sloped more aggressively to hold the food inside more securely.

Coghlan's crimped-edge pie iron cooking in the campfire, held over burning logs and coals

My Favorite Double Pie Irons for Family Cooking

Pie irons are super-efficient for me to cook for myself when I am alone, but if I am cooking for others, they are not. I learned this the hard way! My poor family was stuck waiting as I cooked everyone’s calzones… One.. At.. A.. Time.

I don’t use double pie irons often because I’m usually by myself. But if I do get my family out in the woods with me, then I need to make more food and do it efficiently. Enter, the double pie iron.

My favorite double pie iron is similar to my favorite single pie iron in that it is nice and roomy inside. It’s great for tater tots. It’s especially great for calzones. And it is stellar at making larger sandwiches or making sandwiches two-at-a-time.

Golden-brown toasted bread with ridged grill marks in an open long-handled sandwich press

Coghlan even makes what I consider the dessert-type of pie iron I included above, but as a double pie iron as well. This is a great timesaver if you are not, in fact, camping and cooking alone.

Oddly, the only photo I could find of me using mine was where I was using it for tater tots. I must not have been able to find the one I would normally use on this occasion. This seems to happen to me a lot and is also how I’ve ended up with so many.

Which brings up a good, final point — these are just my personal preferences for which pie irons I use ideally and when, but these are preferences, not rules!

Open double pie iron with tater tots cooking inside, held over hot campfire coals

Similar Posts